A generic "What if?" thread?

[Kyle1987]

OK, right now we have the "What if Bulleid had stayed?" and "What if Nationalisation didn't occur in 1948?" threads open, however these relate to very specific "what if?" questions.

Would it be a good idea to create a generic "What If? - LNER" thread in which a topic is posted (eg. What if the York-Newcastle electrification was continued in 1923? or How would the LNER have looked if WWII never occurred?) and discussed until it runs out of steam, at which point a new question is posed? That way we could save ourselves opening multiple threads and enjoy going over quite a few different hypothetical situation, had history taken a slightly alternate route...

Or should we just open one thread per topic?

[James Brodie]

What if we have a referendum on which what ifs to have? Jim Brodie.


now then how do I get my tongue out of my cheek!

[richard]

I think one thread per topic - perhaps Railway Chat will be the best place for many of these?

I'll re-iterate my usual response that I'm wary of adding too many forums. I much prefer a few busy ones over lots of quiet ones that take up many screens to scroll through.


Richard

[Malcolm]

I think one thread per topic - perhaps Railway Chat will be the best place for many of these?

I'll re-iterate my usual response that I'm wary of adding too many forums. I much prefer a few busy ones over lots of quiet ones that take up many screens to scroll through.


Richard

I tend to agree. "What if?" topics don't tend to crop up all that often, and adding another forum would take up space for something that is not all that busy. Stay with 'Railway Chat".

Malcolm

[Kyle1987]

I think I may have worded myself poorly; I didn't intend to create a whole sub-board simply for "What if?" questions It was the suggestion of only a single topic/thread (eg within Railway Chat - as is the "Hengist - new build" topic) being created, with all questions being made within that. Therefore a new "question" is simply posted beneath the last response of the previous question within said thread

I hope that I'm making sense here (I'm not feeling very eloquent this morning); just wanted to make sure we're all on the ssame page (so to speak )

[richard]

Sure - go ahead! It would be a good place to put such idle wonderings. The only thing is we'll have to keep pointing people towards the thread.


Richard