60113 as a Mikado

[60800]

http://www.rmweb.co.uk/community/index. ... ithdrawal/

[Atlantic 3279]

Novel!

Safety note for others - don't look while driking tea or coffee.

[marksouthcoast]

Perhaps its time to create a new section on the forums sutch as never wazzers and alterinive reality or counterfatial history?.

[S.A.C. Martin]

I rather like that...

[60800]

I prefer it to what Thompson did with her

[Blink Bonny]

Ay up!

That looks rather handsome TBH. Anyone fancy this one?

[Atlantic 3279]

Fancy it? Only if it dresses in black rubber.....

You might have done the decent thing Blackout and posted the link to this fine Gresley specimen rather than the Thompson carbucle:
http://www.rmweb.co.uk/community/index. ... ley-4-8-2/

That should appeal to the man of Perth unless he has already seen it.

The manipulator of those images is clearly rather good at his craft and tooled-up with decent software for the job. The whole album of alternative design history items is worth a look.

I wonder, could he, or somebody with similar skill, have a go at a rendition of the originally proposed West Highland mixed-traffic lightweight 3-cylinder 2-8-0, the East Midlands 2-8-2 P10 coal tank, or even a Gresley 5' 8" wheeled counterpart of the P1s that might have found much wider application and maybe eliminated the later need for the ill-fated P2s and the V2s?

[marksouthcoast]

How about a new thread on planned but unbuilt engines.

[60800]

You might have done the decent thing Blackout and posted the link to this fine Gresley specimen rather than the Thompson carbucle:
http://www.rmweb.co.uk/community/index. ... ley-4-8-2/

I saw that but didn't like it. The de-streamlined P2's looked nice though

[Saint Johnstoun]

The manipulated pictures are very good, but one feature has been missed in these elongated renderings - the boiler design used on the 4-8-2 and 4-8-4 proposals featured a very long smokebox. If our friend was able to rework his 4-8-2 drawing showing that feature with the superheater header covers visible and a vee fronted cab then it would be spot on.

Although not LNER I am very tempted by his LMS Castle! That would certainly upset a few friends of mine who are worshippers of Gods Wonderful Railway! An old Airfix Castle allied to a 4F tender would work!

[marksouthcoast]

If the gwr had let the lms use the castle drawings the red castle might have happened instead of the royal scots.

[kudu]

A fascinating archive.

Prompts me to recollect some other LNER rarities, such as the short-lived Raven 4-10-2 or the interesting results after Gresley's visit to Boston Lodge. I seem to recall an impressive 4-6-4-6-4, but that would challenge the most skillful photographer.

Kudu

[manna]

G'Day Gents

Was there ever a 'Mallett' proposed for the LNER, would be fun with our loading gauge

manna

[Atlantic 3279]

None to my knowledge, but Hughes' team seem to have been looking at a proposal for the early LMS, before the dead-hand of Derby became all powerful and decreed that "Thou shallt build none larger than medium 2-6-0s and 4-4-0s, even unto the company's utter inability to run a proper service" and Mike Edge has a working 4mm model of that Mallet, colloquially known as The Hammer. The early LMS did of course build the Garratts too, complete with vital components such as bearings from the Derby stock-sizes range, suited only too small engines....
I wonder how successfully Hughes and his men would have tackled the difficult UK problem of firebox and ashpan over the coupled wheels, twenty odd years before Riddles had to have his first go? The model certainly suggests a wide firebox over the rear coupled wheel group.

[LNER Fan 60008]

Interesting take on another 2-8-2. Those long Thompson fronts help the aesthetics on this one.

My favorites from his batch of "photos" are the unmodified Great Northern in BR Blue and the Ivatt 4-6-2.